{"text_format":"2","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":2,"sheets":["評価基準表","評価"],"not_rendered":{"charts":0,"images":0,"macros":0,"external_links":0,"defined_names":3,"comments":0,"pivot_tables":0},"unopened":[],"bounds":{"document_bytes":16777216,"sheet_cells":100000,"run_cost":"one","rows_first":2000,"rows_last":500,"rows_between":2000,"halvings":0,"cell_chars":16384,"cell_head_chars":4096},"cells_cut":0,"cells_raw":0,"read":"whole","date_system":"1900"}

{"sheet":"評価基準表","index":0,"n_rows":122,"n_cols":17,"rows_kept":122,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[0,5,2,5],[120,7,121,8],[0,11,0,16],[1,6,2,6],[1,7,2,7],[1,11,1,13],[1,14,1,16],[0,6,0,7],[0,8,2,8],[0,9,2,9],[120,9,121,9],[0,10,2,10],[0,0,2,0],[0,4,2,4],[0,1,2,3],[119,1,119,2],[118,1,118,2],[116,1,116,2],[117,1,117,2]]}
["No.","項番",null,null,"評価基準","基礎点/加点","評価区分",null,"重要度","点数","提案資料及び該当ページ","評価欄"]
[{"$nulls":6},"相対","絶対",null,null,null,"A社評価",null,null,"B社評価"]
[{"$nulls":11},"評価結果","点数","評価コメント\n（任意）","評価結果","点数","評価コメント\n（任意）"]
[null,"調達仕様書"]
[null,"1. 用語の定義",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"2. 調達案件の概要に関する事項",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"2.1 調達件名",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"2.2 調達の背景",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"2.3 調達の目的及び期待する効果",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"2.4 調達範囲",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"2.5 システムの概要",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"2.6 契約期間",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"2.7 作業スケジュール（想定）",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"3. 調達案件及び関連する調達案件の調達単位等",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"3.1 調達案件及び関連する調達案件の調達単位等",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"4． 作業の実施内容に関する事項",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[1,null,"4.1 設計・構築に係る作業",null,"具体的な作業内容、作業を進める上での工夫等を示し、実現性が考慮されており、本業務を実施する上で調整が必要となる関係者、調整事項、調整時期、各調整を行う上での調整プロセス等が明確に示されている。\nまた、設計・構築の作業スケジュールについて、実現性及びリスクに対する根拠等が示されており、全体スケジュールにおけるリスク（遅延を除く）とその対応及び短期間で設計・構築、テスト、移行を行う必要があること等、スケジュール上の工夫点について示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[null,null,"4.2 運用・保守に係る作業",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"5． 成果物の範囲、提出期日等",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"5.1 成果物",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"5.2 納品方法",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"5.3 納品場所",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"6． 満たすべき要件に関する事項",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"7． 作業の実施体制・方法に関する事項",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[2,null,"7.1 作業実施体制",null,"本業務の特性を踏まえ、要員ごとの作業・役割分担、本業務への参画度が明確に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","中",100]
[3,null,null,null,"本業務の特性を踏まえ、指示・命令の系統、人事院等と情報共有を行うための連携図が明確に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","中",100]
[4,null,null,null,"本業務の特性を踏まえ、各役割に求められる経験、能力が明確に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","中",100]
[5,null,null,null,"本業務の特性を踏まえ、各要員の氏名、所属する組織、保有する資格、業務実績、経験年数、能力、本業務への関与度（専任、兼任）緊急時の対応が明確に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","中",100]
[6,null,null,null,"本業務の特性を踏まえ、システムの品質、情報セキュリティを高めるため、情報セキュリティ対策の管理体制が明確に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","中",100]
[null,null,"7.2   要員に求める資格等の要件",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"7.3 情報セキュリティ体制の整備",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"7.4 作業場所",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"7.5 作業の管理に関する要領",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"8． 作業の実施に当たっての遵守事項",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"8.1 機密保持、資料の取扱い",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"8.2 遵守する法令等",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"9． 成果物の取扱いに関する事項",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"9.1 知的財産権の帰属",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"9.2 瑕疵担保責任",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"9.3 検収",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"9.4 監査及び検査",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"10． 入札参加資格に関する事項",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"10.1 受託者に求める資格及び要件",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"10.2 複数事業者による共同提案",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"10.3 入札制限",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"11． 再委託に関する事項",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"11.1 再委託の制限及び再委託を認める場合の条件",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"11.2 承認手続",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"11.3 再委託先に関する事項",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[7,"12． 特記事項",null,null,"本調達の契約終了時に、本調達で導入する機器等の撤去について提案されており、撤去手順や関係者との調整方法が具体的に示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150,"-"]
[null,"13． 付属文書",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"13.1 添付資料",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"13.2 閲覧できる資料",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"14． 資料の閲覧",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"要件定義書"]
[null,"1． 業務要件の定義",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"1.1  利用者",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"1.2 拠点単位のクライアント利用者数",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"1.3 拠点所在地",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"1.4 サービス提供時間",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"1.5 情報システム化の範囲",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,"2． 機能要件の定義",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"2.1 機能概要",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"2.2 利用者提供機能",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[8,null,null,"2.2.1 仮想デスクトップ","利用者及び運用者の負担軽減につながる有益な提案が的確に示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[9,null,null,null,"セキュリティ向上につながる有益な提案が的確に表現されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[null,null,null,"2.2.2 文書作成","-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,null,"2.2.3 表計算","-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,null,"2.2.4 プレゼンテーション","-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,null,"2.2.5 簡易データベース","-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,null,"2.2.6 PDF形式ファイル作成・閲覧等","-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,null,"2.2.7 メールクライアント","-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[10,null,null,"2.2.8 リアルタイムコミュニケーション","利用者及び運用者の負担軽減につながる有益な提案が的確に示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[11,null,null,null,"セキュリティ向上につながる有益な提案が的確に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[12,null,null,"2.2.9 電子メール送受信","利用者及び運用者の負担軽減につながる有益な提案が的確に示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[13,null,null,null,"セキュリティ向上につながる有益な提案が的確に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[14,null,null,"2.2.10 ファイル共有  ","利用者及び運用者の負担軽減につながる有益な提案が的確に示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[15,null,null,null,"セキュリティ向上につながる有益な提案が的確に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[16,null,null,"2.2.11 会議室等予約及びスケジュール管理","スケジュール管理機能にスケジュールの開始前にメール等で事前通知できるリマインダ機能を有しており、機能を利用するための具体策が示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150,"-"]
[null,null,null,"2.2.12 プリント","-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[17,null,null,"2.2.13 Webブラウジング","利用者及び運用者の負担軽減につながる有益な提案が的確に示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[18,null,null,null,"セキュリティ向上につながる有益な提案が的確に表現されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[null,null,null,"2.2.14 統合ディレクトリ  ","-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,null,"2.2.15 内部DNS","-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,null,"2.2.16 NTP","-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[19,null,null,"2.2.17 ファイル転送","利用者及び運用者の負担軽減につながる有益な提案が的確に示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[20,null,null,null,"セキュリティ向上につながる有益な提案が的確に表現されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[21,null,null,"2.2.18 外部接続","利用者及び運用者の負担軽減につながる有益な提案が的確に示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[22,null,null,null,"セキュリティ向上につながる有益な提案が的確に表現されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[23,null,"2.3 システム運用機能",null,"各機能について、利用方法が運用者の視点で具体的に示されており、利用者、運用者の負担軽減やセキュリティ向上等につながる方式が示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[24,null,null,null,"二重障害に備えた追加提案（テープバックアップ等）が提案されており、実現するための具体策が示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[null,"3． 非機能要件の定義",null,null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"3.1 ユーザビリティ及びアクセシビリティに関する事項",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[25,null,"3.2 システム方式に関する事項",null,"現行システムと比較してシステムの変更点が分かるようにシステムの全体イメージが明確に示されている。\n\n","加点","相対","-","大",150,"-"]
[null,null,"3.3 規模に関する事項",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[null,null,"3.4 性能に関する事項",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[26,null,"3.5 信頼性に関する事項",null,"現行システムと比較して信頼性が向上している点が分かるように明確に示されている。\nまた、各種保存データ、設定ファイル等の情報が正確に記録または保存可能な方法が示されている。\n \n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[27,null,"3.6 情報セキュリティに関する事項",null,"情報セキュリティ対策について、「政府機関等の情報セキュリティ対策のための統一基準群（平成28年度版）」に沿って、脅威に対する対策が明確に示されている。\n\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[28,null,null,null,"現行システムと比較してセキュリティが向上している点が分かるように明確に示されている。\nまた、情報セキュリティに対するリスクに対し、「入口対策」「出口対策」「内部対策」の区分け等、具体的な対策が示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[29,null,"3.7 情報システム稼働環境に関する事項",null,"サーバ、ネットワーク機器が人事院で用意したラック及び電源の仕様に適合していることが具体的に示されており、機器のサイジングの根拠が利用者の視点から明確に示されている。\nまた、円滑な運用及びセキュリティを考慮した説明が示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[{"$nulls":4},"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[{"$nulls":4},"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[{"$nulls":4},"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[{"$nulls":4},"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[{"$nulls":4},"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[{"$nulls":4},"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[{"$nulls":4},"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[30,null,"3.8 テストに関する事項",null,"テスト実施計画書の記載項目、テストにおける関係者及び留意事項とその対策が整理され、その内容に基づいたテスト方針が具体的に示されている。\nまた、テスト内容が容易に把握でき、安定稼働に向けて必要な作業であることが明確に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[31,null,"3.9 受入テスト支援",null,"主管課及び各局課等が実施する受入テスト内容を理解した上で、受入テスト支援の実施内容が具体的に示されており、特に重要となる仮想デスクトップの受入れテスト計画（主管課への先行導入等）が具体的に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[32,null,"3.10 移行に関する事項",null,"移行全体概略図(案)及び移行スケジュール等を用いて移行の全体像が具体的に示されており、利用者及び運用への影響を踏まえたデータの移行方針及び軽減案が示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[33,null,null,null,"移行作業を実施する上での課題、リスクについて、想定される発生・完了時期とその根拠が示されており、本業務に有効となる対応方法等が具体的に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","大",150]
[null,null,"3.11 引継ぎに関する事項",null,"-","-","-","-","-","-","-"]
[34,null,"3.12 教育に関する事項",null,"教育の目的が具体的に示されている。\nまた、主管課や利用者の対象者に応じて、教育の目的を達成するための教育手段が具体的に示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","小",50,"-"]
[35,null,"3.13 運用に関する事項",null,"具体的な作業内容、作業を進める上での工夫等を示し、実現性が考慮されており、定常運用項目及び非定常運用項目に対して、項目単位に実施頻度、作業の詳細が明確に示されている。","加点","相対","-","大",150,"-"]
[36,null,"3.14保守に関する事項",null,"具体的な作業内容、作業を進める上での工夫等を示し、実現性が考慮されており、定常運用項目及び非定常運用項目に対して、項目単位に実施頻度、作業の詳細が明確に示されている。","加点","相対","-","小",50,"-"]
[null,"その他"]
[37,"追加提案",null,null,"上記以外の項目で本業務に関して有益な提案がされており、提案内容が妥当と判断できるための根拠が示されている。\n","加点","相対","-","中",100]
[38,"プレゼンテーション",null,null,"①プロジェクト全体管理責任者として、経験や知識、コミュニケーション能力、責任感、本プロジェクトに対する強いコミットメントが確認でき、適任であると論理的に判断できる。\n②質疑に対し、誠実、かつ、根拠を持った分かりやすい回答ができていると論理的に判断できる。\n\n","加点","相対","-","小",50]
[39,"ワークライフバランスに関する指標等\n（複数の認定等に該当する場合は、最も配点が高い区分により配点を行う）",null,null,"①女性の職業生活における活躍の推進に関する法律（女性活躍推進法）に基づく認定（えるぼし認定企業）\n\n１段階目（※１）：50点\n２段階目（※１）：80点\n３段階目：         160点\n行動計画（※２）：25点\n\n②次世代育成支援対策推進法（次世代法）に基づく認定（くるみん認定企業・プラチナくるみん認定企業）\n\nくるみん　　　　　：50点\nプラチナくるみん：80点\n\n③青少年の雇用の促進等に関する法律（若者雇用促進法）に基づく認定\n\nユースエール認定：80点\n\n※１労働時間等の働き方に係る基準は満たすこと。\n※２女性活躍推進法に基づく一般事業主行動計画の策定義務がない事業主（常時雇用する労働者の数が300人以下のもの）に限る （計画期間が満了していない行動計画を策定している場合のみ）。","加点","-","絶対","-",160]
[40,"基礎点",null,null,"遵守証明書に示す要件を全て満たすこと。","基礎点","-","絶対","-",740]
[{"$nulls":5},"基礎点",{"$f":"SUMIF(F4:F120,\"基礎点\",J4:J120)","v":740},"総計\n(基礎点+加点)",null,{"$f":"G121+G122","v":6000}]
[{"$nulls":5},"加点",{"$f":"SUMIF(F4:F120,\"加点\",J4:J120)","v":5260}]

{"sheet":"評価","index":1,"n_rows":4,"n_cols":1,"rows_kept":4,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}
["A"]
["B"]
["C"]
["D"]